Review: Topic Selection Process for Technology Appraisals. A Consultation Document

The article reviewed here is a Department of Health document titled ‘Topic Selection Process for Technology Appraisals. A Consultation Document’ and freely available here. The interesting question to ask before reading this document is how would an organisation efficiently choose health technologies to review – what process would they use for this? One approach to answering this can be found in the current document.

The document begins with many notable objectives. The objectives address the technology selection process and these include transparency and providing professionals and the public with the opportunity to contribute. Cutting the time for selection down to 3 months is of the goal with a simple outcome measure.

Following on from this is some background to this consultation. The document follows on from ‘High Quality Care For All’ (freely available here) in which references are made to the technology appraisal process. The current process is described in part 3 which illustrates this with a flow diagram. There are many steps in the process and health ministers are involved at the later stages. In the diagram it is noted that the minimum time for drug licensing is 9-12 months for instance. After this is a summary of each stage of the process. For instance there is a National Horizon Scanning Centre at the University of Birmingham which plays role of ‘horizon scanning’ for ‘pharmaceutical and biopharmaceutical products’. We learn about NICE’s ‘topic selection team’. A number of different panels convene to discuss the technologies and these are rated. The ratings are then used in the selection process. Various roles are also expanded upon in this section.

The revised process is then described in part 4 which identifies 5 decision points in the process and highlights those which are new. These changes are further discussed in subsequent sections. New criteria were selected when filtering technologies as well as at other stages. Another change occurs with the topic selection consideration panels who no longer use a 5 point scoring system but instead consider the scores from the NICE topic selection team. The third decision point involves some steps being removed and the decision for forwarding technologies to the next stage being retained within NICE. Decision point 4 involves a meeting between ministers and the NICE team and the final decision point is the ministerial referral.

In section 5, the selection criteria are discussed and as well as the evidence base, the role of ‘professional judgement and experience’ is emphasised. Under the criteria there are a number of factors for consideration which were either not included previously or have since been modified and these include ‘burden of disease’, ‘potential for therapeutic benefit’, ‘patient population’ for small populations, resource impact, ‘variation in practice’, ‘timeliness and urgency’ and ‘policy importance’. There follows a section on key questions for the consultation process and instructions on responding to the document. Finally there are two appendices one for the existing selection criteria, another for the proposed new criteria and one containing summary details of the consultation process itself.

This is a consultation document which encourages contributions from those with an interest in this area and gives insights into some of the complex processes that take place in the appraisal of new technologies.


If you have any comments, you can leave them below or alternatively e-mail


The comments made here represent the opinions of the author and do not represent the profession or any body/organisation. The comments made here are not meant as a source of medical advice and those seeking medical advice are advised to consult with their own doctor. The author is not responsible for the contents of any external sites that are linked to in this blog.


  1. What’s up, is there anybody else here?
    If it’s not just all bots here, let me know. I’m looking to network
    Oh, and yes I’m a real person LOL.



  2. What’s up, is there anybody else here?
    If there’s anyone else here, let me know.
    Oh, and yes I’m a real person LOL.

    See ya,


  3. This look interesting,so far.
    If there are any real people here looking to network, leave me a post.
    Oh, and yes I’m a real person LOL.



  4. This looks cool so far, what’s up people?
    If it’s not just all bots here, let me know. I’m looking to network
    Oh, and yes I’m a real person LOL.

    See ya,


  5. I have been trying very hard to quick smoking. I learned that I have to have realistic expectations – quitting isn’t easy, but it’s not impossible either. More than 3 million Americans quit every year.

    Understand that withdrawal symptoms are TEMPORARY. They usually last only 1-2 weeks.

    Know that most relapses occur in the first week after quitting, when withdrawal symptoms are strongest and your body is still dependent on nicotine. Be aware that this will be your hardest time, and use all your personal resources – willpower, family, friends, and the tips in this booklet – to get you through this critical period successfully.
    Know that most other relapses occur in the first 3 months after quitting, with situational triggers – such as a particularly stressful event – occur unexpectedly. These are the times when people reach for cigarettes automatically, because they associate smoking with relaxing. This is the kind of situation that’s hard to prepare yourself for until it happens, so it’s especially important to recognize it if it does happen. Remember that smoking is a habit, but a habit you can break.

    Realize that most successful ex-smokers quit for good only after several attempts. You may be one of those who can quit your first try. But if you’re not, DON’T GIVE UP. Try again.


  6. Hi

    I’ve looked a trailer for the “2012”. I was interested in this theme.
    Please advise me a good site on this topic.
    And what do you think about the end of the world 2012.



    • Dear Dyexpediegige,
      Thank you for ‘comment’. I’m afraid I don’t really know a good site on this topic. Perhaps you might try one of the search engines.
      As for the end of the world in 2012, this is outside of my area of expertise. Talking outside of my field of expertise, I’m not aware of any reason why the planet earth should suddenly cease to exist in three years time. Perhaps a book on positive psychology might be the ideal antidote.



    • How very good of you to join us. I can’t speak for the others but I’m doing fine. How are you?


  7. I download tons of apps to my iPod touch, and they transfer to my dads computer when I sync it. When my dad syncs his iPhone, they get transferred to it. Now he wants do disable app downloading because he has to delete so many apps. How can I make it so iTunes doesn’t sync all the apps I download to his phone?

    unlock iphone 3g 3.0


    • Nice to see you here. Pleasantly surprised that this post has generated such a lot of varied and positive interest! Justin


  8. Dear comrads!

    Is it a deal to change itunes to mp3? I say NO 🙂 Its really annoying not being able to play iTunes tracks with my $300 iriver!
    Digging for a solution brings certain results. To convert iTunes to MP3 I used this tool drm removal ( or something like this, please ask me – will find that web again). I don’t care what is drm – what I read, its something dealing with protection and nothing about iTunes.
    But this tool really works for me and it converted quickly my iTuines entire library, including video files!.

    What is your way of doing it? Why iTunes makes this foolishness? I didn’t like ipods at all! They simple stuck and suck!
    What is that drm that I loose converting my itunes to mp3?

    thanks in advance!


  9. Hello everyone, I’m bran-new to the site, but I have been looking for this place for a very long time ‘n I am so happy I finally got here.

    I am 21 years of age and doing my bachelors at Oxford.

    I am the sort of hombre who enjoys to try original things. Right now I’m fabricating my personal solar panels. I am doing it all by myself without the assistance of my staff. I am using the net as the only way to acheive that. I encountered a very amazing website that explains how to create photovoltaic panels and wind generators. The internet site explains all the steps required to making solar panels.

    I’m not sure about how accurate the information given there is. If some experts over here who have xp with these work can have a see and give your feedback in the thread it would be great and I would really appreciate it.

    Thanks for reading this. You guys are great.


  10. Hi! My name is Dean. I’m 29 years old. I came across this forum while doing some research and decided to join. I hope to share and gain insight with/from you all. I’m trying to be the best me I can be, so I’m trying to stay informed, open-minded, and optimistic.
    Thanks, Dean


  11. hi everyone,
    I am Sandra from Geneva, Switzerland. It feels nice to be here. I want to ask something. As a part of the new year resolution I have decided to make myself very beautiful. To begin with I want to reduce dark circles under my eye. This hydrolyze reviews website seems promising. Anyone used them or have any reviews about them. Any other advise for reducing dark circles under the eyes?


  12. Nothing can be more absurd than the practice that prevails in our country of men and women not following the same pursuits with all their strengths and with one mind, for thus, the state instead of being whole is reduced to half.
    Quotation of Plato


  13. I’m the sort of hombre who loves to taste brand-new stuff. Presently I’m building my own photovoltaic panels. I’m managing it all alone without the aid of my staff. I am utilizing the net as the only path to acheive that. I saw a really amazing website that explains how to make solar panels and so on. The site explains all the steps needed for constructing solar panels.

    I’m not really sure about how correct the data given there is. If some experts over here who had experience with these things can have a look and give your feedback in the page it will be great and I would highly value it, cause I extremely take an interest in solar panel construction.

    Tnx for reading this. U guys rock.


    • Dear Ann,

      Thanks for your comments. Perhaps I could have been clearer in my article – this is a review of a paper on topic selection for technology appraisals. I don’t remember reading anything in the paper about pancakes. As for pancake recipes, I’m afraid I don’t really have any pancake recipes. Perhaps you might try adding some lemon juice or else try one of the celebrity chefs?




  14. Hey there I’m just dropping in to say hi and introduce myself! Im a computer nerd that came upon this forum and hope to become an active member soon! So if you happen to have and computer questions feel free to ask. Otherwise see you all on the boards.


  15. Deep within man dwell those slumbering powers; powers that would astonish him, that he never dreamed of possessing; forces that would revolutionize his life if aroused and put into action.


    • Thanks for those profound thoughts. This consultation document on a topic selection process for technology appraisals has certainly stimulated some interesting responses Regards Justin


  16. Well, If you have ever thought about writing some script to automate those things that you are doing many times every day, then you have a great and easy way to automate the entir e process. It comes without saying that a few imacros and firefox add-ons will automate all actions related to a browser (Mozilla). If you want to automate your system as such, then you may need some other script, straightforward commands can automate your system. Even a beginner can automate things using a simple software called as sikuli all you need to do is to tell Sikuli what to do by giving some screenshots and straightforward commands.
    A GUI will be used with Sikuli. Sikuli is an open siurce scripting application that will use a mixture of simple commands like click, type, wait and so on. There’s no internal API support, it simply searches the screen for the image in the screenshot-that implies that you’ll be able to use it for anything. There’s literally no limit on how you employ it to automate things.
    This is too good to be true, but if you watch the subsequent video, you will come to know that this can be extremely easy. If you visit their home page, you get a lot of tutorials and support; it can be a cake walk even for beginners. You’ll check the video as well as get the software at


  17. Good day , my name is David Hasselhop

    What a awesome place that you have here, keep up the good work.

    I would like to share on of the tips from my blog with you,

    Blogging Tip # 1: Keep It Short.

    Persons can get quite effortlessly distracted, so a short blog post can have a lot additional effect than a lengthy 1. When you have a whole lot to say about a matter, then its better to break it down into two or three posts instead of preserving it as 1 that may be too lengthy.

    If you ever find that you might want to write a long post, and can’t break it up into pieces, remember to allow it to be very readable by adding bullet points, images or a numbered sequence.

    You can also allow it to be a lot more readable by bolding words and adding much of subtitles. Most men and women might be scanning through the info; this makes it less difficult for them to obtain the bits and pieces they are trying to find.

    Preserving your website readable makes people desire to return. If they prefer to return they will bookmark your web page and recommend it to other people with social bookmarking. This could be the sort of viral response you must be aiming for.

    For more tips and tricks please visit my Blog



  18. Hi there my name is Stevie Levine and I live in York, that is around the Midlands of The uk. I am 36 years old and also I have been hitched for Five years. I have 4 small children. I look forward to chatting with you all in here.


  19. Hi , my name is Daisy

    It happens to be a superb site that you have here, keep up the really good work.

    I would like to share one of the tips from my blog with you,

    Blogging Tip # 3: Put The Reader In Your memory.

    If you write, you’ll want to bear in mind you aren’t writing for your self, but you’re writing for another person. Why is that visitor coming for your web-site? Why did he obtain it using that certain search phrase you might be promoting?

    A individual that is certainly seeking a particular topic of information does not need to hear how your day went. If you’re retaining a sort of journal with your blog then that’s fine, but if you’re developing a company in your niche, and are targeting a specific keyword for facts, your personal life has no relevance in that post.

    That’s not to say, on the other hand, you must not add personality to your blog posts. You are able to make them rich and lively with out getting into much of own info.

    There’s a separate place on your blog that you simply must write some personal details about your self, and that would be the “About Me” web page.

    You’d be surprised at how several people will click on this page if they’re considering making a buy from your site. Some Internet consumers want to obtain out much more about the organization or particular person they are purchasing from. Your “About Me” page have to be personalized so that you just become a real figure for them, and they feel they can trust you.

    For more tips and tricks please visit my Blog

    Kind regards


  20. Hai,

    I just came across to from search engine and I found very interesting.
    I hope, i can make lot’s of new friend here 🙂


    • Dear Briteqwote,
      I think that Einstein was essentially asking the question ‘why can we understand the world around us’ and was referring more specifically to the ability to characterise some essential truths about the universe in concise mathematical terms. Had he had the pleasure of visiting this forum however, he may have well have retracted his words


  21. Hi,

    I’m newbie here and came to from search engine.

    I really think this forum was great and nice to be here.

    I’m work on health related job and i have a blog which giving out info about Health News Information

    I love for being health and i do anything to get my health target 🙂

    Healthy life will make your life more longer and your body will become more strong also by run a healthy life will make your face looking fresh.

    I really hope everyone here as healthy as i am but if not then you should change your life style immediatly for your own benefits 🙂


  22. Hi!,

    I just came across to from google and I found very interesting.
    I hope, i can make lot’s of new friends here at 🙂


  23. Hello!

    Im new to the site. really looking forward to meeting new people, seeing what they have to say and just really chilling on some social network other than facebook. bleh. like i said, i am me, now who are you?

    Take care!


  24. what good is respect if you cant get a man with it? I am a female that has always been single, I think guys see me as the kind you take seriously and respect while all they are looking for is a good time. The problem is the number of guys looking for a good time far exceeds the number of guys looking for something serious/real so that means no dates for me! whats the use of being a good girl when good girls get ignored?

    sorry offtop!


  25. Hello!

    Very new to this….. and just want to say hello to everyone!!! Would love to hear from you all……re your experiences of forums, interests I like gardening, reading and chilling out with friends

    Keep smiling


  26. What’s Happening i am new here. I stumbled upon this chat board I find It very useful and its helped me out a lot. I hope to contribute and assist others like its helped me.

    Thank You, See Ya Around.


  27. Hi guys,

    My name is Thomas and I am from Stirling in the UK. I have recently discovered this forum and I like it very much.
    I am a bit shy so I wont write much about myself but maybe when I will get more confortable, you guys will get to know me better!
    My main hobbies are playing piano and watching movies. I also like outdoor activites but the temperature has been very bad for the last days or so here in Stirling.

    I was wondering if anyone else here is from the UK too?

    I am happy to have joined this forum!


    PS: Sorry if this was posted in the wrong section. I could not find the right one!


  28. Two-thirds of Americans struggle to reach their weight loss goal, seriously jeopardizing long term health and taking precious years off their lifespan. If current trends continue, over the next two decades, experts believe the number of overweight and obese will swell to over 80% of all adults.

    Many people have the desire to lose weight and have put forth the effort countless times. The end result is typically a failure, as permanent weight loss requires a major shift in lifestyle which is difficult for most. Some people fall for fad diet pills which promise massive weight loss in a short period of time without the need for calorie restriction or exercise. This is not the way to lose weight and can even endanger your health.

    The only proven method to achieve permanent weight loss is eating a reduced calorie diet highlighted by plenty of vegetables and a regular exercise routine. Sometimes our metabolism stalls and we hit a diet plateau. Reducing calories or increasing exercise doesn’t make the scale move. This is a survival mechanism which has evolved over the millennia and which likely served our ancestors well, but today simply compounds the problem. There are some ‘tricks’ savvy dieters use to help overcome the inevitable weight plateau and achieve their target goal.

    If offtop del this post, please


  29. Hey guys,

    My name is William and I am from Stirling in the United Kingdom. I have freshly discovered this forum and I like it alot.
    I am a bit shy so I wont talk much about me but maybe when I will get confortable, you will get to know me better!
    My main hobbies are painting and watching movies. I also like outdoor activites but the temperature has been bad for the last weeks or so here |.

    I was wondering if someone else here is from the united Kingdom too?

    I am glad to have joined this forum!
    Have a nice day!


    PS: Sorry if this was posted in the wrong topic. I could not find the right one!


  30. Am new here, got to by searching google and definitely like it here, will enjoy my stay for sure hehe 🙂

    By the way If anyone of you is also fascinated in florida online jobs see my signature


  31. I recently watched the Gloss refine Small screen program, which made me unquestionably curious. He told a story that seemed unusual. Namely, they were lots of women who worked in a huge mill, the casting of wool. Was shown the entire production modify, and the conditions under the control of which people come out all right in Taiwan. It is known that these areas are known predominantly from cheaper labor. But what has happened in the factory than my expectations. People there were not at all good facilities. In furthermore to the extraordinarily straitened working conditions, to partake of them to their limits.

    All this worked loophole in the cold and heating work halls there were on the contrary an abstraction. Furthermore, their execute was splendid hard. Extended motkami slog of wool is not the easiest, and its forging itself requires exceptional punishment and precision. Extraordinary is the in reality that purely in the companionship was well-grounded in a place where the recovered czyściło sheep’s wool, cleanliness prevailed. All things shone, but only because that this wool is not suitable in the service of need at the beat when it is soiled during production.

    Tv programs


  32. good afternon! amazing news I discovered site which run xrumer service! somebody have opinion about service at website xrumer ??? I want to try out it. Is it reliasable to get new vistors in that way? I want to get my site in greater search results!


  33. Not sure if it’s my web browser simply I still previously had never free time to update and so i am still employing InternetExplorer 7 but while visiting your web page My husband and i came across some form of unusual characters everywhere in the web site, in case if it’s actually significant I merely thought I would inform you about. similar to Warning: Not possible modify head string … and so on. It Is a little odd because for me web-sites like as well as my very own 1 las vegas car insurance do appear with no problems.


  34. Am new here, discovered by searching yahoo and truly like it here, will enjoy my stay for sure hehe 🙂

    P.S. If somebody is too fascinated in auto insurance pleases check out my signature


  35. Hi guys and girls, can a person be so kind and help me out? I got here another day through yahoo but now cannot discover once again the post I was reading that time . And before someone asks, no I’m not blond simply not that excellent with pcs hehe.

    p.s. If anyone of you is also interested in point and shoot digital cameras look my Sig.


  36. Am new here, found trough google and definitely like it here, will enjoy my stay for sure

    P.S. If someone is also interested in flight you can look my signature


  37. by the way My apologies, the english language is just not my main language. My spouse and i found some type of strange letters all over the web page, in case it is critical I merely thought I would inform you about. like Attention: Not possible modify head information … etc. That is most probably my browser , simply because I still got virtually no free time to upgrading and so i’m continue utilising firefox 3.0.14 but webpages just like as well as my personal one cheap flights to nassau do perform free of troubles for me, thus its a bit strange.


  38. Unsure if it is actually my System because I yet have absolutely no free time to upgrade and i am continue employing Chrome 3 but while seeing the webpage My husband and i observed some form of unusual letters everywhere in the site, in case it is essential I only just considered I’d let you know. such as Notice: Impossible change header string … etc. That is a little bit abnormal since for me my site virtual assistant and the standard sort like, bing perform great for me.


  39. If you have a plan to visit Poland you have to see our site where you will find the best places in Poland.
    Poland it’s a beautifull country aspecialy small villages near the sea. We present the best places you have to sea if you are in Poland.

    Country sitemap

    Best regards
    Martin rozwoj


  40. Hi Everybody, i would just like to make an intro to everyone at

    Your forum is fantastic! Usually when I visit forums, I just come across junk, but this time I was very surprised, finding a informative forum containing great information.

    Thanks people at and keep this fantastic effort up.

    modern sculptures Finger Puppet modern Soft Furnishings kids science parties modern coffee tables


  41. Now a days i just have cereal with milk and sugar or toast with marmalade, jam, or honey, marmalade and jam are not the same, marmalade is made from oranges and jam is made from other fruit. 🙂


  42. I have afternoon tea, with sandwiches, cakes, and, of course, a cup of tea.
    At the weekends i often invite their friends to have a chat over a cup of tea. =)


    • Dear Fetleldlaft,
      Thank you for your considered response to the above paper. Yours is a unique perspective which appears to have been overlooked by the authors who make no mention of baked desserts or aromatic beverages in their analysis of topic selection processes for technology appraisals.


  43. Recently in Poland to hear a lot of celebration commemorating the creation of Solidarity. There are many discussions on this subject and some of them are very controversial. I wonder whether in other countries, people know what it is and if they have solidarity on this issue a sentence?



  44. Am new here, found trough bing and definitely like it here, will enjoy my stay for sure hehe 🙂

    I’m not certain whether this is allows but I am considering educational software, and thus I am living a link in my signature that has a lot usefull material about that issue.


  45. Very good to be here, one of the best looking forms I’ve seen in terms of design.Wish I can get to meet a lot of you, read a lot of great information and also making contributions my own share.

    I have a internet site about forex robot and if the person is considering about that idea I wish they will pay a visit to it.


  46. Heya guys and girls, can somebody if possible help me out? I come here another day through google but now can’t discover once again the post I have been reading that day :(. And before somebody asks, no I am not blond merely not that excellent with computer systems hehe.
    Muack 🙂

    I just come from an other site with a couple of very usefull guidance about Mobile Phone Recycling, if someone also prefers to know about that field see my signature.


  47. I am new here.Never been in forum before.Please accept me to be a part of this forum.I guarantee to share.

    I just now come from an other site with lots of very usefull important information about Symptoms of Diabetes, if someone also does need to know about that topic see my signature.


  48. New here, got to by searching google and really like it here, will enjoy my stay for sure hehe 🙂

    I have a websites about colon cancer and if the person is curious about that idea I wish they will view it.


  49. Hello !

    I’m new on this forum so I introduce me…

    My name is Max I’m 21 years old, I’m a Deutsch in USA.

    My hobbies : holdem poker, baseball and video games...

    Nice to meet you.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s